BlackballingTimTebow

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Monday, 23 April 2012

Shouting in Shul About the Prayer for the State of Israel

Posted on 21:58 by Unknown
Originally posted 10/30/05...

There was a shouting match this past Shabbat morning at the 8:30 minyan at the Bnai Yeshurun synagogue in Teaneck. The Gabbai added the single word sheteheh to the Prayer for the State of Israel. That meant he said that we prayed that the Lord protect Israel and that the State will be the first flowering of our redemption -- instead of praying that the Lord protect it because it is the beginning of our redemption.

The policy at CBY officially is to add that will be qualifier. The 9:00 minyan always does. The 8:30 has not -- based on a "don't ask, don't tell" understanding. But then recently the Rabbi got wind of this unfortunate laxity. He scolded the Gabbai and insisted that the policy of qualifying the prayer be rigidly enforced. The resultant shouting match followed.

By Shabbat afternoon the rabbi felt compelled to make a speech between Minhah and Maariv about the matter. He chastised everyone ... for violating the charter of the synagogue, for being negative and just plain reminded folks that if they did not like his leadership they could choose to form another shul or release him in five years at the conclusion of his contract.

No matter. The issue here is not about a rabbi, but about why anyone cares about what words are said in this "prayer" for the State of Israel.

Common sense should tell everyone in the synagogue that this whole prayer is unimportant, peripheral, second rate, and really not a part of the davening.

First off, the "prayer" is recited by the gabbai, not the hazzan. Second, the "prayer" usually is recited in a monotone, not chanted, and from the side of the bimah, not from the front and center of the synagogue. Third, the "prayer" is recited after the Torah reading and before the Musaf service -- in between the "real" parts of the davening. It seems to me to be placed in a tertiary context that makes it even less official than the personal mesheberach blessings recited for individuals who receive aliyot to the Torah.

You don't have to be an expert in Jewish liturgy to conclude that this relatively recent "prayer" is treated like an afterthought, recited quickly, that has been pasted in to our davening. In fact in some synagogues, the text is actually pasted into the back cover of the siddur.

So really, why would anyone argue, shout or pout about what word is or is not said in this "prayer".

What people should be concerned with is real prayer-book reform. We should be integrating a real prayer for the modern state of Israel into the middle of the actual prayer services of our tradition. We should have the chazzan chant it properly from the bimah. We should have the congregation join in responsively or together with the chazzan in singing the prayer with joy.

Naturally, we should not hem and haw liturgically about the importance and centrality of the State of Israel. It is real. Most of our shul members have been there. Most of our shul members have been inspired by the State and its history. The State of Israel is a factual, powerful, pervasive, long-lasting creator of religious moods and motivations.

Honestly, I have never heard a shul member discuss, express interest in, or argue about the reinstitution of the cultic sacrifice in the Temple. Yet that topic has much more of a central place in our synagogue liturgy.

Those who shout at each other about this or that word in a second or third rate "prayer" -- one that is mumbled by the gabbai from the side of the bimah in between shacharit and musaf -- ought to reconsider.

Yes it is time to shout and argue about promoting the thanksgiving, praise and petition concerning the modern State of Israel as a real and central theme of all of our synagogue prayers.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in brooklyn, hebrew, history, israel, New York Jews, orthodox, prayer, rabbis, religion, synagogues, teaneck, zionism | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Thanksgiving Turkey Drumstick Jack-O-Lantern Pumpkin Pie Table Song - A Lone Pumpkin Grew
    Thanksgiving will be upon us soon and we sing traditional holiday songs at our Thanksgiving dinner. Here are the words to one of our favorit...
  • Update on the Insults: A Battle Over a Book: Haym Soloveitchik v. Talya Fishman
    Our once-upon-a-time teacher at Yeshiva University has panned a new book about rabbinic cultural development. It's a veritable battle ov...
  • Is Sigourney Weaver Jewish?
    Now it is far-fetched that anybody would think that actress Sigourney Weaver is Jewish. No, Sigourney Weaver is not a Jew. The tall actress ...
  • Is John Oliver Jewish?
    John Oliver is filling in for Jon Stewart this summer, 2013. He is one funny dude. The Daily Show with Jon Stewart Get More: Daily Show Full...
  • Free Download of the Soncino Talmud in English Online at Halakhah.com: 25,000+ satisfied customers a month
    The Soncino Babylonian Talmud English translation is online - at a site that is not anti-Semitic or polemical. Download the Talmud in Englis...
  • Was Christopher Columbus Jewish?
    Yes, Christopher Columbus was a Jew according to some historians. Charles Garcia, writing via CNN, summarized the case for Columbus the Jew ...
  • Is Paul Volcker Jewish?
    No, we do not think that former Federal Reserve Chairman Paul Volcker is a Jew. According to reporter Roni Sofer of the usually reliable Is...
  • Rav Soloveitchik's Dissertation at the University of Berlin
    In honor of the 20th yahrzeit of the Rav's passing (on Hol HaMoed Pesach, the 18th of Nisan, in 1993) and of the 110th year since his bi...
  • How Peter Salovey is related to Rav J. B. Soloveitchik
    In a comment to a Yale Daily News story , Peter Salovey, president of Yale explained his relationship to Rav Soloveitchik. (Hat tip to Billy...
  • Note to Self: Do not wear Geox shoes in the rain or snow. They have little holes in soles!
    We wear Geox shoes almost all the time nowadays. They are truly more comfortable for someone like us who mainly sits at a desk throughout th...

Categories

  • 9/11 (1)
  • Alan F. Segal (1)
  • amazon (33)
  • antiSemitism (14)
  • apocalyptic (1)
  • apple (11)
  • archetypes (35)
  • are-they-jewish? (73)
  • ariely (1)
  • art (18)
  • atlantic beach (3)
  • audio book (1)
  • barack (20)
  • baseball (2)
  • beyond belief (1)
  • bible (48)
  • bloggers (12)
  • bobby knight (1)
  • book club (3)
  • book serialization (14)
  • books (83)
  • boteach (2)
  • brooklyn (10)
  • buddhism (5)
  • christianity (59)
  • circumcision (3)
  • copyright (4)
  • daf yomi (4)
  • daphne (1)
  • dead-sea-scrolls (4)
  • dirty tricks (4)
  • egalitarianism (3)
  • einstein (2)
  • film (20)
  • footnote (2)
  • gay rights (12)
  • golf (8)
  • google (15)
  • haaretz (5)
  • haggadah (9)
  • Harvard (1)
  • hasidism (17)
  • health (36)
  • heath (1)
  • hebrew (18)
  • history (12)
  • Holocaust (18)
  • huckabee (1)
  • hullin (3)
  • humor (76)
  • inventions (30)
  • iPad (12)
  • iPhone (9)
  • Is-it-kosher? (46)
  • islam (19)
  • israel (108)
  • juergensmeyer (2)
  • kabbalah (12)
  • kaddish (6)
  • kindle (33)
  • kosher (16)
  • kugel (1)
  • kushner (1)
  • laptops (1)
  • lex talionis (1)
  • madoff (15)
  • madonna (4)
  • Maimonides (5)
  • meditation (22)
  • menorah (2)
  • Merkin (10)
  • microsoft (1)
  • Minnesota (8)
  • Mishnah (2)
  • money (65)
  • mormons (5)
  • morton smith (3)
  • music (29)
  • nazis (3)
  • netanyahu (1)
  • New York Jews (46)
  • norman lamm (5)
  • obama (19)
  • orthodox (86)
  • Passover (20)
  • politics (91)
  • pools (13)
  • prayer (92)
  • Purim (9)
  • rabbis (124)
  • rahm emanuel (1)
  • rav (15)
  • recipes (2)
  • religion (170)
  • schachter (1)
  • science (45)
  • shaiel (1)
  • sikhs (3)
  • smoking (2)
  • software (6)
  • soloveitchik (17)
  • soul (2)
  • sports (47)
  • statins (1)
  • supreme court (1)
  • Surfing (1)
  • synagogues (73)
  • talmud (117)
  • Talmudic Books (30)
  • teaneck (37)
  • terrorism (6)
  • texas (1)
  • Thanksgiving (4)
  • theodicy (1)
  • tim tebow (3)
  • universities (56)
  • videos (19)
  • wikipedia (1)
  • wine (3)
  • wingnuts (22)
  • women (64)
  • yeshiva (41)
  • yiddish (5)
  • youkilis (2)
  • zev zahavy (21)
  • zichron ephraim (12)
  • zionism (21)

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (187)
    • ►  August (5)
    • ►  July (30)
    • ►  June (23)
    • ►  May (25)
    • ►  April (30)
    • ►  March (33)
    • ►  February (17)
    • ►  January (24)
  • ▼  2012 (313)
    • ►  December (31)
    • ►  November (23)
    • ►  October (16)
    • ►  September (15)
    • ►  August (20)
    • ►  July (20)
    • ►  June (34)
    • ►  May (19)
    • ▼  April (38)
      • NY Times: Rabbi Zev Zahavy call for Fair Immigrati...
      • NY Times 1953: Rabbi Zev Zahavy Calls for National...
      • 55 Years Ago: Rabbi Zev Zahavy Calls for Iraq Peace
      • 200 of My Dad's Sermons Reported in the New York T...
      • Times: Religion, Religion, Religion
      • Is Jimmy Kimmel Jewish?
      • Slate Magazine: How ex-Orthodox men Learn About Re...
      • Is Madonna Jewish?
      • This Week - Six New Kindle Talmud Tractates in Eng...
      • Srugim Blog: Rav Amar to Rav Sharki at the Kotel, ...
      • Yom Haatzmaut Addition for Your Daily Prayerbook
      • A prayer for Israel Independence Day
      • Is Mitt Romney Jewish?
      • Shouting in Shul About the Prayer for the State of...
      • Who wrote the Prayer for Serenity?
      • Are iPhones, Android devices, iPads, and Blackberr...
      • Times Mag: Does Swimming Make You Smarter?
      • How can we better Memorialize the Shoah in our Syn...
      • English Translation of Bavli Meilah for Kindle
      • Beinart responds to Rosen in The Daily Beast
      • Is Kevin Youkilis Jewish?
      • Talmud: The Ten Commandments are Embedded in the S...
      • Monday Special: "God's Favorite Prayers" a Free Ki...
      • Will the War Against Religious Terrorism Ever End?
      • Times Total Hatchet Job: Jonathan Rosen v. Peter B...
      • One Day Sunday 4/15 Free Kindle Talmudic Books
      • What is "Displaced Talmudic Energy?"
      • Tzvee's Talmudic blog in New York Magazine
      • On “Reflections on the Influence of the Rov on the...
      • WSJ: Golf Practice, Daily Talmud Study, and "the i...
      • The Haggadah as an American Best Seller
      • Free Talmudic Book for Your Kindle: Kosher Talmud ...
      • Anti-Abortion Activist Lou Engle Hijacks and Twist...
      • The Passover Seder: When we all must become childr...
      • Rabbi Eleazar ben Azariah - a Star of the Seder
      • iPad Haggadah, Passover and Seder App and online S...
      • Congratulations to my father's successor Rabbi Sch...
      • NYMagazine: A Talmudic Discussion of New York Scan...
    • ►  March (39)
    • ►  February (31)
    • ►  January (27)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile