BlackballingTimTebow

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Friday, 1 June 2012

TNR: Peter Schäfer Pans Daniel Boyarin's Jesus Book

Posted on 09:32 by Unknown
Are all the basic theological ideas of Christianity found in earlier forms of Judaism? Boyarin says yes indeed, Schäfer says no way.

In TNR Peter Schäfer has negatively reviewed Daniel Boyarin's new Jesus Book.

The bottom line according to Schäfer is, "BOYARIN’S BOOK leaves the reader irritated and sad. It has very little that is new to offer—and what appears to be new is wildly speculative and highly idiosyncratic. Even judged by its commendable intentions—to win over dogmatic defenders of the perfect uniqueness of Christianity or Judaism—it is disappointing."

The idiosyncratic nature of the book can be seen from its TOC:
1. From Son of God to Son of Man
2. The Son of Man in First Enoch and Fourth Ezra: Other Jewish Messiahs of the First Century
3. Jesus Kept Kosher
4. The Suffering Christ as a Midrash on Daniel
Epilogue: The Jewish Gospel
Here we have the menu: Christology mixed with kosher mixed with messiah talk. The agenda of the book is confusing if it exists at all.

In the Foreword to the book Jack Miles writes,
In chapter 3 of the book you are about to read, titled “Jesus Kept Kosher,” Boyarin writes:
Most (if not all) of the ideas and practices of the Jesus movement of the first century and the beginning of the second century—and even later—can be safely understood as part of the ideas and practices that we understand to be “Judaism.”. . . The ideas of Trinity and incarnation, or certainly the germs of those ideas, were already present among Jewish believers well before Jesus came on the scene to incarnate in himself, as it were, those theological notions and take up his messianic calling.
Miles does no favor to Boyarin by citing up front a section with phrases like these:
  • "Most (if not all)"
  • "present among Jewish believers"
  • that we understand to be “Judaism”
  • "or certainly the germs of those ideas"
Such qualifiers defeat any claim, rendering it impenetrable to understand and impossible to challenge. From what Professor Schäfer says, he is sure that Boyarin is wrong and sure that Boyarin does not account for basic scholarship in the field in which he writes, saying in a most biting scholarly criticism, "All the relevant pre-Christian Jewish sources as well as the New Testament sources have been exemplarily presented and analyzed by Martin Hengel in his seminal book, The Son of God: The Origin of Christology and the History of Jewish-Hellenistic Religion, published in many editions, of which Boyarin seems unaware."

Whether Boyarin is "unaware" or "aware" what Schäfer means to say is that he does not "cite" this work in the book and that diminishes its value as a work of scholarship. Further, Schäfer makes it utterly clear that he is not convinced of the value of the core insights or analyses of this book.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in are-they-jewish?, christianity, religion | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Thanksgiving Turkey Drumstick Jack-O-Lantern Pumpkin Pie Table Song - A Lone Pumpkin Grew
    Thanksgiving will be upon us soon and we sing traditional holiday songs at our Thanksgiving dinner. Here are the words to one of our favorit...
  • Update on the Insults: A Battle Over a Book: Haym Soloveitchik v. Talya Fishman
    Our once-upon-a-time teacher at Yeshiva University has panned a new book about rabbinic cultural development. It's a veritable battle ov...
  • Is Sigourney Weaver Jewish?
    Now it is far-fetched that anybody would think that actress Sigourney Weaver is Jewish. No, Sigourney Weaver is not a Jew. The tall actress ...
  • Is John Oliver Jewish?
    John Oliver is filling in for Jon Stewart this summer, 2013. He is one funny dude. The Daily Show with Jon Stewart Get More: Daily Show Full...
  • Free Download of the Soncino Talmud in English Online at Halakhah.com: 25,000+ satisfied customers a month
    The Soncino Babylonian Talmud English translation is online - at a site that is not anti-Semitic or polemical. Download the Talmud in Englis...
  • Was Christopher Columbus Jewish?
    Yes, Christopher Columbus was a Jew according to some historians. Charles Garcia, writing via CNN, summarized the case for Columbus the Jew ...
  • Is Paul Volcker Jewish?
    No, we do not think that former Federal Reserve Chairman Paul Volcker is a Jew. According to reporter Roni Sofer of the usually reliable Is...
  • Rav Soloveitchik's Dissertation at the University of Berlin
    In honor of the 20th yahrzeit of the Rav's passing (on Hol HaMoed Pesach, the 18th of Nisan, in 1993) and of the 110th year since his bi...
  • How Peter Salovey is related to Rav J. B. Soloveitchik
    In a comment to a Yale Daily News story , Peter Salovey, president of Yale explained his relationship to Rav Soloveitchik. (Hat tip to Billy...
  • Note to Self: Do not wear Geox shoes in the rain or snow. They have little holes in soles!
    We wear Geox shoes almost all the time nowadays. They are truly more comfortable for someone like us who mainly sits at a desk throughout th...

Categories

  • 9/11 (1)
  • Alan F. Segal (1)
  • amazon (33)
  • antiSemitism (14)
  • apocalyptic (1)
  • apple (11)
  • archetypes (35)
  • are-they-jewish? (73)
  • ariely (1)
  • art (18)
  • atlantic beach (3)
  • audio book (1)
  • barack (20)
  • baseball (2)
  • beyond belief (1)
  • bible (48)
  • bloggers (12)
  • bobby knight (1)
  • book club (3)
  • book serialization (14)
  • books (83)
  • boteach (2)
  • brooklyn (10)
  • buddhism (5)
  • christianity (59)
  • circumcision (3)
  • copyright (4)
  • daf yomi (4)
  • daphne (1)
  • dead-sea-scrolls (4)
  • dirty tricks (4)
  • egalitarianism (3)
  • einstein (2)
  • film (20)
  • footnote (2)
  • gay rights (12)
  • golf (8)
  • google (15)
  • haaretz (5)
  • haggadah (9)
  • Harvard (1)
  • hasidism (17)
  • health (36)
  • heath (1)
  • hebrew (18)
  • history (12)
  • Holocaust (18)
  • huckabee (1)
  • hullin (3)
  • humor (76)
  • inventions (30)
  • iPad (12)
  • iPhone (9)
  • Is-it-kosher? (46)
  • islam (19)
  • israel (108)
  • juergensmeyer (2)
  • kabbalah (12)
  • kaddish (6)
  • kindle (33)
  • kosher (16)
  • kugel (1)
  • kushner (1)
  • laptops (1)
  • lex talionis (1)
  • madoff (15)
  • madonna (4)
  • Maimonides (5)
  • meditation (22)
  • menorah (2)
  • Merkin (10)
  • microsoft (1)
  • Minnesota (8)
  • Mishnah (2)
  • money (65)
  • mormons (5)
  • morton smith (3)
  • music (29)
  • nazis (3)
  • netanyahu (1)
  • New York Jews (46)
  • norman lamm (5)
  • obama (19)
  • orthodox (86)
  • Passover (20)
  • politics (91)
  • pools (13)
  • prayer (92)
  • Purim (9)
  • rabbis (124)
  • rahm emanuel (1)
  • rav (15)
  • recipes (2)
  • religion (170)
  • schachter (1)
  • science (45)
  • shaiel (1)
  • sikhs (3)
  • smoking (2)
  • software (6)
  • soloveitchik (17)
  • soul (2)
  • sports (47)
  • statins (1)
  • supreme court (1)
  • Surfing (1)
  • synagogues (73)
  • talmud (117)
  • Talmudic Books (30)
  • teaneck (37)
  • terrorism (6)
  • texas (1)
  • Thanksgiving (4)
  • theodicy (1)
  • tim tebow (3)
  • universities (56)
  • videos (19)
  • wikipedia (1)
  • wine (3)
  • wingnuts (22)
  • women (64)
  • yeshiva (41)
  • yiddish (5)
  • youkilis (2)
  • zev zahavy (21)
  • zichron ephraim (12)
  • zionism (21)

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (187)
    • ►  August (5)
    • ►  July (30)
    • ►  June (23)
    • ►  May (25)
    • ►  April (30)
    • ►  March (33)
    • ►  February (17)
    • ►  January (24)
  • ▼  2012 (313)
    • ►  December (31)
    • ►  November (23)
    • ►  October (16)
    • ►  September (15)
    • ►  August (20)
    • ►  July (20)
    • ▼  June (34)
      • Is Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor Jewish?
      • Is Peter B. Madoff Jewish?
      • Where is the Fifth Avenue Synagogue?
      • New Yorker's Talmudic Account of a Madoff Panel
      • J. Ezra Merkin settles Madoff-related lawsuit with...
      • Video: The Jewish Channel Exposes Anti-Zionist Wor...
      • Slate: What is the Penalty for Eating a Non-Kosher...
      • AP: Blackwell Burke Law Firm has Sued ConAgra Food...
      • Book Notice: Relics for the Present: Contemporary ...
      • Is David Yerushalmi Jewish?
      • SPIEGEL: A Tired and Withdrawn Pope Ignores the Va...
      • Happy Father's Day? Celebrate the Life of Your Dad
      • Please Excuse My Son's Absence from Class. He will...
      • Teaneck's Moshe Butler pleads guilty to criminal ...
      • Get the Kindle Babylonian Talmud in English
      • A Hebrew Charter School is Seeking Approval for a ...
      • Are Mormons Jewish?
      • Are New Jersey Jews Jewish?
      • The Astounding Koren Talmud Bavli has a little sis...
      • Is Philosophy Jewish?
      • Is it Kosher? Rabbi Yona Metzger, Chief Rabbi of I...
      • Love at First Sight - the Koren Talmud Bavli Berak...
      • Is Quentin Tarantino Jewish?
      • Talmudic Sexual Practices and Menstruating Women -...
      • WSJ Video Interview with Israeli-Iranian Singer Ri...
      • Check out The Hebrew Scriptures in Judaism and Chr...
      • Times: Vatican Cracks Down on What is Kosher Catho...
      • Teaneck Deputy Mayor Adam Gussen for Congress agai...
      • The Introduction to Zev Zahavy's book, "Whence an...
      • Is Bar Refaeli Jewish?
      • Sunday - Free Kindle Book - Define Judaism by Tzve...
      • ADL: Arabic Talmud has 'dangerous and defamatory' ...
      • PUBLIC PRAYER AND THE SHALIACH TZIBUR - free in PDF
      • TNR: Peter Schäfer Pans Daniel Boyarin's Jesus Book
    • ►  May (19)
    • ►  April (38)
    • ►  March (39)
    • ►  February (31)
    • ►  January (27)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile